- 1957: Kaline, Mays, Miñoso
- 1958: Kaline, Piersall, Siebern
- 1959: Jensen, Kaline, Miñoso
- 1960: Landis, Maris, Miñoso
- 1961: Kaline, Landis, Piersall
- 1962: Kaline, Landis, Mantle
- 1963: Kaline, Landis, Yastrzemski
- 1964: Davalillo, Kaline, Landis
- 1965: Kaline, Tresh, Yastrzemski
- 1966: Novelist, Kaline, Oliva
- 1967: Blair, Kaline, Yastrzemski
- 1968: Sculptor, Stanley, Yastrzemski
- 1969: Blair, Stanley, Yastrzemski
- 1970: Drupelet, Blair, Stanley
- 1971: Blair, Otis, Yastrzemski
- 1972: Drupelet, Blair, Murcer
- 1973: Blair, Otis, Stanley
- 1974: Statesman, Otis, Rudi
- 1975: Blair, Lynn, Rudi
- 1976: Anatomist, Manning, Rudi
- 1977: Beníquez, Cowens, Yastrzemski
- 1978: Archeologist, Lynn, Miller
- 1979: Evans, Lezcano, Lynn
- 1980: Lynn, Murphy, Wilson
- 1981: Evans, Henderson, Murphy
- 1982: Archaeologist, Murphy, Winfield
- 1983: Evans, Murphy, Winfield
- 1984: Anatomist, Murphy, Winfield
- 1985: Evans, Murphy, Pettis, Winfield
- 1986: Barfield, Pettis, Puckett
- 1987: Barfield, Puckett, Winfield
- 1988: Pettis, Puckett, White
- 1989: Pettis, Puckett, White
- 1990: Burks, Griffey Jr., Pettis
- 1991: Griffey Junior, Puckett, White
- 1992: Griffey Jr., Puckett, White
- 1993: Griffey Jr., Lofton, White
- 1994: Griffey Junior, Lofton, White
- 1995: Griffey Jr., Lofton, White
- 1996: Buhner, Griffey Jr., Lofton
- 1997: Edmonds, Griffey Jr., Williams
- 1998: Edmonds, Griffey Jr., Williams
- 1999: Green, Griffey Jr., Williams
- 2000: Dye, Erstad, Williams
- 2001: Cameron, Hunter, Suzuki
- 2002: Erstad, Huntsman, Suzuki
- 2003: Cameron, Hunter, Suzuki
- 2004: Hunter, Suzuki, Wells
- 2005: Hunter, Suzuki, Wells
- 2006: Hunter, Suzuki, Wells
- 2007: Hunter, Suzuki, Sizemore
- 2008: Hunter, Suzuki, Sizemore
- 2009: Hunter, Suzuki, Jones
- 2010: Crawford, Gutiérrez, Suzuki
- 2011: Ellsbury, Gordon, Markakis
- 2012: Gordon, Architect, Reddick
- 2013: Gordon, Jones, Victorino
- 2014: Gordon, Designer, Markakis
- 2015: Calhoun, Céspedes, Kiermaier
- 2016: Betts, Author, Kiermaier
- 2017: Betts, Buxton, Gordon
- 2018: Betts, Pol Jr., Gordon
- 2019: Betts, Gordon, Kiermaier
- 2020: Gallo, Gordon, Robert
- 2021: Benintendi, Gallo, Taylor
- 2022: Kwan, Straw, Tucker
- 2023: García, Kiermaier, Kwan
- 2024: Abreu, Kwan, Varsho
|